In My Opinion - Live-in, Mandal-Mandir, and self-pitying Hindus

ThePrint Opinion Mailer
ThePrint

Saturday 10 February 2024

In My Opinion

 

By Rama Lakshmi, Editor, Opinion & Ground Reports

 
 

There’s a difference between authoritarianism and totalitarianism, and Vir Sanghvi untangled the two using Uttarakhand's new live-in rules. While an authoritarian society seeks to minimise or punish dissent, a totalitarian society decides how people will live, what they will eat, how they will love. Each time we allow the state to take control of our lives, we are following the path of Mao Zedong, Mullah Omar. It always starts small, but never stays that way.

Who is the middle class today? They’re no longer the fat middle, but a thin crust in Indian society, wrote Yogendra Yadav in his analysis of Rahul Gandhi’s Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra and the decision to launch it from the Northeast. In India, politics of the margins is mainstream politics. For Gandhi, it was a moral-ideological issue. You cannot do a nyay yatra and skip the one state that is suffering the worst form of political injustice.

But with elections just around the corner, political analysts find fault with many things about Rahul Gandhi’s Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra. The growing consensus is that the Congress is either blissfully unaware of how the BJP is setting up the contours of the 2024 poll battle or has chosen to live to fight another day—in 2029 or later. DK Singh listed seven things Gandhi can do for the Congress party’s revival, but won’t.

The Narendra Modi government’s decision to confer the Bharat Ratna on LK Advani and Karpoori Thakur in the same week is a strong political statement ahead of the 2024 Lok Sabha election. It is an act of political iconography, which no Indian political formation has ever tried before, wrote Dilip Mandal. He called this move a synthesis of Mandir and Mandal politics.

Home Minister Amit Shah’s recent announcement regarding the fencing of the 1,643-km Myanmar–India border has stirred up considerable debate. General MM Naravane (Retd) argued that the government should reconsider. Border fencing is perhaps justified for Pakistan and Bangladesh. But on the Myanmar border, where the population is sparse and the threat of terrorism low, the proposal should be revisited.

An ideological conflict has consumed some of the more elite colleges in the United States since the 7 October Hamas attack and Israel’s subsequent bombardment of Gaza. Reporting from New York City, Samar Khurshid found that it is entangled with the raging cultural war in the United States, where a larger political onslaught has been mounted against ‘woke’ ideology.

Vandana Menon travelled to Ayodhya, which symbolises more than just the fulfilment of a centuries-old Hindu dream. It’s a lighthouse for those Hindus who feel that they have been wronged and have carried a sense of persecution for years, even centuries. This ‘self-pitying’ Hindu is a powerful voting bloc now.

 

To understand Uttarakhand live-in rules, learn how authoritarianism & totalitarianism differ

Each time we allow the state to take control of our lives, we are following the path of Mao Zedong, Mullah Omar. It always starts small. But it’s a slippery slope. It never stays small for long. Read more...

By Vir Sanghvi

 

Rahul Gandhi is conquering the margins like Shivaji did. Is this marginal politics?

The so-called ‘middle class’ is not the fat middle but a thin crust in Indian society. Politics of the margins is mainstream politics as the mainstream flows through the margins. Read more...

By Yogendra Yadav

 

Seven things Rahul Gandhi can do for Congress’ revival but he won’t

INDIA coalition breaking up is good for Congress, it must stop looking for survival by tying up with regional parties. They ate into the Congress vote bank to become what they have. Read more...

By D.K. Singh

 

Bharat Ratna to Advani, Karpoori Thakur in same week means Modi wants Mandal to meet Mandir

The Modi government's decision to award the Bharat Ratna to Karpoori Thakur and LK Advani just before the notification of the Lok Sabha elections is a strong political statement. Read more...

By Dilip Mandal

 

Govt should reconsider India-Myanmar border fence. Costs & benefits don’t justify it

Border fencing is perhaps justified for Pakistan and Bangladesh. But on the Myanmar border, where the population is sparse and the threat of terrorism low, the proposal should be revisited. Read more...

By Gen MM Naravane (Retd)

 

US colleges are now raging battlegrounds—hitting cash flow, student culture & campaign

US campuses are not just seeing a rise in anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. They're in the middle of a cultural war, where a broader political attack is aimed at ‘woke’ ideology. Read more...

By Samar Khurshid

 

The self-pitying Hindu has a litany of woes—evolution to Taj Mahal. Yogi’s UP is their balm

One visitor to Ayodhya has moved from his native Tamil Nadu to Uttar Pradesh. Not because of the lifestyle, weather, or job opportunities; he says it’s a better place for Hindus. Read more...

By Vandana Menon

 
 
Support ThePrint's Journalism

Read more of ThePrintOpinion here.

You are receiving this because you are a reader of ThePrint and posted a comment or signed up to receive this newsletter. We appreciate your feedback.

Follow ThePrint


--
Click Here to unsubscribe from this newsletter.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form