In My Opinion - Sengol, Vishwaguru & the Congress’ Hinduism

ThePrint Opinion Mailer
ThePrint

Saturday 27 May 2023

In My Opinion

 

By Rama Lakshmi, Editor, Opinion & Ground Reports

 
 

The week’s heady G20 event in Kashmir and the grand feet-touching reception at Papua New Guinea have firmly raised the global stature of India, and by extension, PM Modi. It is the Vishwaguru moment. If Modi accrues all the benefits of this tag, DK Singh asked a provocative question: Does the opposition have a match for the Vishwaguru? Going by the stated positions of their leaders, they would rather leave this ‘Modi vs who’ question for later. That just throws up way too many contenders, including Priyanka Gandhi Vadra.

Just as the new Parliament inauguration led to an opposition boycott, after Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge tweeted asking why President Draupadi Murmu isn’t the one presiding over the ceremony, came the Sengol sceptre controversy. It drove a wedge in politics and history again. Praveen Chakravarty wrote that the tradition of handing over Sengol to a new king is a Chola dynasty custom, though scholars of the Sangam era date it even earlier. The most iconic historiography of a Sengol is an 18th-century painting in the famous Meenakshi Amman Temple in Madurai in which the goddess is handing over the sceptre to the Nayaka kings. There is another painting in the Ramalinga Vilasam palace of the 18th-century Sethupathi kings in the Ramanathapuram district where Goddess Rajarajeshwari is seen giving a Sengol to a Sethupathi king.

In contemporary Tamil politics, the most famous incident involving a Sengol happened in Madurai in July 1986 when J. Jayalalitha handed it to MGR. Now, going by tradition, the Sengol must be handed over to Modi by President Draupadi Murmu.

Dilip Mandal, however, reminded readers that Jawaharlal Nehru has set a precedent by delivering the Independence Day speech with his ‘tryst with destiny’ address and also inaugurating major national institutions.

Yogendra Yadav wrote about the sorry state of Hindi journalism in India today. A TV panel discussion that he participated in after the Karnataka election results made him conclude that the world of TV news is an “upper-caste affair”. The anchor’s narrative was simple: BJP has been defeated not by its own incompetence and corruption but by some dirty caste politics, part of a diabolic design that would culminate in the nationwide demand for caste census.

Sixty Muslim candidates from the BJP won in the Uttar Pradesh municipal elections this month, a sign of a thriving, inclusive democracy, wrote Amana Begam. The BJP’s decision to field so many Muslims is a substantial stride towards promoting a more diverse political landscape.

What exactly happened in the subcontinent after the decline of the Harappan Civilisation is a frequently asked question in the past seven decades. Some said a ‘Dark Age’ followed, other said painted grey ware. Bhagwanpura village threw up answers. Disha Ahluwalia wrote that before the Bhagwanpura excavation, the association of Harappans with people who used Painted Grey Ware was unknown and blurry.

Let’s stay with history for a bit. And don’t roll your eyes, but 7th century Indian engineers actually built robots. Anirudh Kanisetti brought evidence from Buddhist texts.

Two horrific events divided by a decade tell us about the predatory medical system in Bihar. Jyoti Yadav brought us this deep-dive Ground Reports on how poor Dalit women were robbed of their wombs a decade ago, and now, once again, there is a kidney scam that has left women in a state of paralysing fear and despair.

Shubhangi Mishra travelled to Chattisgarh and Madhya Pradesh and brought us articles on the Congress party’s outreach to temple and priests. The ambitious corridor project at the Kaushalya temple is part of CM Bhupesh Baghel’s Hinduism project, on top of his cow dung buyback. She also looks at the new temple priest outreach by the Congress party in Madhya Pradesh – but it is easier said than done. The priests want ownership of temple land – a matter festering in files and courts for years.

 

Vishwaguru vs who in 2024? Oppn has multiple answers if it chooses to look beyond Rahul Gandhi

Among a dozen PM contenders and pretenders, the opposition has three potentially disruptive choices—a Dalit, a woman and an OBC leader. Read more...

By D.K. Singh

 

Laud Modi govt for bringing Sengol to new Parliament. Now it must make Murmu hand it over too

For all the hype generated over the Sengol, the govt must follow the tradition to the T. Goddesses to Jayalalithaa, a woman figurehead must preside over it. Read more...

By Praveen Chakravarty

 

Modi right to inaugurate Parliament building. Opposition ignoring precedent set by Nehru

While it would be better for the Modi government to invite President Droupadi Murmu at the inauguration function as a matter of moral practice, it is not a legal requirement. Read more...

By Dilip Mandal

 

Hindi media’s nostalgia for Brahmin supremacy isn’t over. It’s unapologetic, in your face

One question did not leave me, though: How has the world of Hindi journalism, especially Hindi news television, sunk to this depth? Read more...

By Yogendra Yadav

Success of BJP-backed Muslim candidates showcases the strength of Indian democracy

The positive response from Pasmanda Muslims to BJP's initiative is particularly noteworthy, it reflects that they are prioritising their own welfare over political rhetoric. Read more...

By Amana Begam

 

What came after Harappan Civilisation? This small Haryana village has answers

Before the excavation at Bhagwanpura, the association of Harappans with people who used Painted Grey Ware was not known. Read more...

By Disha Ahluwalia

 

Medieval Indian engineers in the 7th century built robots. Powered by water and clockwork

Using hydraulics and clockwork, engineers could make wondrous devices that are now lost. These were more credible than claims about pre-modern Indian technology such as UFOs and genetic engineering. Read more...

By Anirudh Kanisetti

 

Bihar’s Dalit women at the mercy of greedy doctors—robbed of uterus in 2012, kidneys now

Bihar has changed, but not for poor Dalit women who continue to be victims of doctors running blacklisted clinics. They end up with stolen uterus or kidneys—and a huge financial debt. Read more...

By Jyoti Yadav

 

MP Congress is courting Hindu priests. But temple land promise is going to be tricky

Resolving the vexatious temple land issue in Madhya Pradesh is easier said than done. But the goal of courting the priest community won't be easy for Congress either. Read more...

By Shubhangi Misra

 
 
Support ThePrint's Journalism

Read more of ThePrintOpinion here.

You are receiving this because you are a reader of ThePrint and posted a comment or signed up to receive this newsletter. We appreciate your feedback.

Follow ThePrint


Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form