In My Opinion - Pathaan, BBC documentary and Muslim supremacy

ThePrint Opinion Mailer
ThePrint

Saturday 28 January 2023

In My Opinion

 

By Rama Lakshmi, Opinion and Features Editor

 
 

India: The Modi Question, a BBC documentary and Pathaan were the two most talked about video content in India this week. One was purely political and was banned. The other was pure entertainment but was made political.

Pathaan, Vir Sanghvi wrote, isn’t just another Hindi movie. It is important in the battle for a tolerant India, free from hatred and communally charged bullying.

The BBC documentary, on the other hand, is a product of the British establishment, and is uniquely authoritative, wrote Shruti Kapila. It is not the outcome of a bleeding-heart liberal. But Sheshadri Chari asked if the British Foreign Office and the BBC still believe that they are above the Supreme Court of India and that they can reopen the Gujarat riots case as if ‘India that is Bharat’ is still under Her Majesty’s Government.

Writing on RSS’ Mohan Bhagwat’s recent caution against Muslim supremacy, Amana Begam Ansari said that there are some upper-caste Muslims today who still live in the glory of the past — they don’t shy away from taking pride in an ‘invader’ ruling India even as they complain about ‘majoritarianism’.

And PM Narendra Modi has been speaking about reaching out to Pasmanda and Bohra Muslims, DK Singh revealed that the BJP’s media minders went into a tizzy, making desperate calls to journalists across TV channels, newspapers, and agencies not to report that news. Why? The fear is of upsetting its core Hindu voters.

The BJP’s politics in Kerala is floundering. It is a divided lot, and its state chief K. Surendran is just not cutting it, wrote Anand Kochukudi. The state calls for a different approach and not the aggressive politics he represents.

Finally, do read our deep-dive feature on the shadowy world of spurious drugs. Sagrika Kissu travelled to low-scale units that manufacture drugs of low quality with poor oversight to unravel the world that produced the cough syrups that allegedly killed children in Uzbekistan.

 

Pathaan is not just any other Hindi movie. It’s a battle for India

Given the frenzy of Hindutva right's boycott campaign, many believed that Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan had flopped even before it was released. We are seeing how wrong they were. Read more...

By Vir Sanghvi

 

BBC Modi documentary row highlights highly risky nature of India’s new image wars

In blocking any circulation or mention of the documentary on social media platforms, PM Modi has reinforced his image and actions as those of a strongman. Read more...

By Shruti Kapila

 

Modi’s victories have nailed the canard on 2002 riots. BBC should worry about its credibility

'India: The Modi Question' documentary raises more questions than it answers. Its content, intent and timing suggests BBC is rushing on a path where angels would fear to tread. Read more...

By Seshadri Chari

 

Muslim supremacy not a ghost invoked by Bhagwat. Problem lies in how the Owaisis respond

Muslim elites don’t shy away from taking pride in ‘invaders’ ruling India but complain about ‘majoritarianism’. This must change for sake of communal harmony. Read more...

By Amana Begam

Why BJP didn’t want PM Modi’s words about Pasmandas, Bohras, and Church to come out

While PM Modi advocates outreach to sections of minorities, his BJP colleagues are wary of upsetting the party's core support base. Read more...

By D.K. Singh

 

Kerala BJP is a divided house under K Surendran. The Tamil Nadu model isn’t working

The bumbling Surendran’s failures have been masked by way of aggression, but the gaffes have become a recurring feature. Read more...

By Anand Kochukudy

 

Inside India’s shadow pharma industry — dingy drug units, cash payments, poor inspection

ThePrint visited drug units in Modi Nagar to see what keeps them running. Death of 18 children in Uzbekistan after they allegedly consumed a spurious drug has hurt India’s image of pharmacy to the world. Read more...

By Sagrika Kissu

 
 
Support ThePrint's Journalism

Read more of ThePrintOpinion here.

You are receiving this because you are a reader of ThePrint and posted a comment or signed up to receive this newsletter. We appreciate your feedback.

Follow ThePrint


Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form